When the Owner Promises Yashan
Most owners who say their flour is yashan mean it. What else could be an issue?
Walk into a bakery or a pizza shop and ask whether it is yashan. More often than not, many owners and mashgiachs will look you in the eye and say yes: our flour is yashan.
They mean it. Most of the owners I have spoken with are sincere, careful people who went out of their way to buy yashan flour. That deserves respect.
But the flour is yashan and everything here is yashan are two different promises.
The halacha itself I’ll assume you know. If you want to review it, the Mishnah Berurah 489:45 is a good place to start. This piece is only about the practice: what can still come in through the side door of a shop that sincerely bought yashan flour.
The dough can be yashan while what is added to it is not.
The bakery
The main sack of flour is only one of the grain products in a bakery. Here is what else is usually there:

- Sourdough starter. A starter is fed every day, often from whatever flour is on hand. If it was fed with fresh flour, the loaf carries it.
- Bench and dusting flour. The flour on the table and the peel is often a separate, cheaper bag that nobody thinks to ask about.
- Malted barley flour and malt syrup. Many bread flours have malted barley added at the mill, and malt syrup goes into bagels and many breads. Barley in America is mostly chadash.
- Vital wheat gluten. It comes from a different supplier than the flour, and the yashan question applies to it too.
The pizza shop
The dough may be yashan. Look at what surrounds it:

- Semolina on the peel. Semolina is durum wheat, a spring crop, and it is usually the first item of the season to turn chodosh.
- Breaded and fried sides. Breadcrumbs, panko, batter and coated fries are bought in, not made from the shop’s flour.
Not everything is a question
To keep this in proportion: chodosh applies only to the five grains, which are wheat, barley, oats, rye and spelt. Rice, corn and other non-grain foods are never chodosh, as long as nothing from the five grains is mixed in. Some items, like the beer above, also have recognized leniencies. The goal is not to be suspicious of every crumb. The goal is to know where the real questions are.
Why the hashgacha matters
An owner’s word covers what the owner knows. A hashgacha covers what the owner may never have thought to check.
Here in Los Angeles, the RCC, Kehilla and the OU all certify yashan as an added option. I have spoken with each of them, and each confirmed the same thing: even where the flour is yashan, other ingredients can come in that are not. That is exactly what a certification body is there to catch. He sees the invoices, checks what was bought in, and checks again when suppliers change.
That last part matters more than people realize. Yashan status is not permanent. A shop that was fully yashan last season may have switched suppliers after the fall cutoffs, with no one meaning any harm.
A reliable hashgacha doesn’t replace the owner’s good faith. It adds a second layer on top of it.
How to ask, respectfully
You don’t need to cross-examine anyone. Three simple questions do the job:
- Is the yashan under hashgacha, or is it the shop’s own word?
- Which items are yashan: everything, or only the bread and pizza?
- Is it on the current certificate?
Before you go, check the L.A. Yashan List. It shows which bakeries and pizza shops are verified, which are yashan only for select items, and which still need confirming.
English of the pasuk follows Sefaria’s translation.